dizmo | Okay. Managed to somewhat organize my thoughts.

Not all that in-depth, but...

Well. That was. Well. My reaction to the book isn't gonna be nearly so in-depth or interesting as a lot of the analysis floating around, and, really, won't contain anything new.. and, in fact, the last half or so is gonna focus largely on.. well.. how I'm gonna deal with the book in

desperatefans, on account of PLAYING SNAPE, AND EVERYTHING. Ahem. But here we go.

If R.A.B. isn't Regulus Black... yeah, whatever.

Once Slughorn was introduced as a former head of Slytherin, I should have KNOWN Snape would be, ah.. making some kind of exit. Because.. yo, replacement. ;)

So. Tobias and Eileen. Not exactly what I expected Sev's parents to be named. But I kinda like it.

Snape's house! Books! Wine! Random hexing of Wormtail to get his ass to stop eavesdropping! Ahahahah!

Scrimgour... you can blow me. Really.

All the relationships? Well.. okay, whatever. ;)

Snape killing Dumbledore. Or as I've referred to it in spoiler-free areas.. "OMG! SPOILER SPOILERED SPOILER!" I am of the school of thought that says Snape's a good guy still, and it was totally at Dumbledore's request. (If anyone hasn't read the various much-better-written justifications of that theory, I'll link upon request.) Poor Snape's gonna have a real rough go of it come book seven, but.. I think he's going to have a huge part in the eventuall downfall of Voldie. And, of course, once again, Harry goes and leaps to the easiest conclusion to make. I think that's even giving Dumbledore less credit that he deserves, but then... When you see your old-wise-mentor get killed IN FRONT OF YOU, you're not likely to analyze it to the degree that readers will.

And he's the Half-Blood Prince! That one floored me. In retrospect, I probably could have foreseen it, but.. Well, I didn't. This was such a Snape-a-riffic book in general. Woo.

Okay. And now, non-DF-ers can probably ignore the rest, unless you're particularly interested in how HBP's gonna affect my characterization.

In one month, Sevvie is going to.. suddenly become a much less popular guy. ;) I mean, hey, yeah, on the one hand.. he really isn't gonna have to worry much about Voldie coming after him anymore, but... Yeah. And can I say angst? Yes. I thought I could. When you have to kill the only person you ever really actually trusted... Yeah. He's not really going to contest the vitriol that I'm sure's gonna arise over this, because he pretty much agrees with it.

That, and he's gonna be a whole lot more careful over what times he drops by chat, and who's there, because.. Really. ;) And somehow.. I get the idea that he's gonna get kicked out of

df_orderhq. Caaaaaaaall it a hunch. *grin*

Threaded | Top-Level Comments Only

Hey! I'm Megan's friend Meredith, and I added you to my FL. And I'll be back to comment about the HP spoilers once I finish the book :D

I've only read half the book, but I've spoiled myself from here to England and back, so here goes. This last book confirmed that I cannot stand Harry Potter. Can't stand him. I know he's a teenager, and they're not all that bright to begin with, and he's a boy, and they're not all that bright to begin with, either, but really. Get a clue.

I'm sad to hear that Slughorn is replacing Sevvie (that name will never not be funny). I was afraid of that when Dumbledore said "former head of Slytherin." Poor Severus.

The chapter with Snape's house is still my favoritest of all the chapters in the HP books. Wall-to-wall books! Eeeeee!

I know some Snape fans are upset by the latest developments (and I sort of have to wonder where they were for the past five books, because Snape is not and never has been a nice person), but I can't wait to see where it goes.

eeee!

I have to agree with you, that Snape did it on Dumbledore's wish. And that R.A.B. is Regulus.

I have a theory/question, maybe you can give me your thoughts on it. At the end, when Harry and McGonagall enter what is now her office (Dumbledore's old office) and see his picture added to the rest of the headmaster and headmistress'...won't Harry still be able to talk to him? Just as Dumbledore spoke to them before his death?

Oh, Snape's a right bastard. I love that. It makes his character much more interesting. ;)

I must admit, I freaked a bit on first read, before I calmed down and looked at it a bit more rationally. But I think the only reason I'd be disappointed is if book seven proves that not only is he a bastard, but he really IS an utterly evil bastard, simply because I think he's been set up to be much more complex and shades-of-gray than that, and it would be rather disappointing on a sheer character development sense. But.. Jo's the author, not me. ;)

As for Harry... He's.. Well, at least he's somewhat more mature than last book, but still. Yeah. Rather thick.

Yes, I do believe it's entirely likely that he will. And I HOPE that Dumbledore's portrait clears Snape, to a degree. Or something.

Oh, yeah, I'd be disappointed by that, too. His complexity is what makes him the most likeable character in the book. It's certainly not his personality. ;)

I'm a little nervous given how one-dimensional some of her characters are (I'm looking right at you, Dudley Dursley), but she's done well with Snape so far. The really upsetting thing is that, given recent developments, there's probably no way he's going to make it out of the next book alive. :(

Yeah. Adore Snape as a character, really wouldn't wanna have dinner with him.

And yeah. She has done a good job with Snape. I've pretty much resigned myself to him most likely dying in book seven, but, as I've put it to a few people, "It's going to be a heroic redemptive death that SAVES EVERYONE and makes Harry feel like a COMPLETE DOUCHE." *sage nod*

Everything you just said about Sevvie-kins being not evil...I agree. Yeah. I've read the the theories too, and it just all makes more sense to me that way. I was not a happy camper after I finished the book, but now that I have it in my mind that he's not eeevil, I feel much better.

I definitely was not expecting him to be the HBP either. That one shocked me.

R.A.B. has to be Regulus.

And Scrimgour is just...a git.

As for DF...heh...yeah, I'm thinking that McGoogles isn't going to be so keen on Snape continuing to be in

df_orderhq. *wink*

Yes. The theory-reading made me feel somuchbetter too, cuz, dude, I like Snape, and I wasn't entirely keen on having to COMPLETELY REVAMP his characterization. ;)

But yeah. Snape as HBP floored me.

And yeah. Something about Dumbledore's killer being in the Order... Not quite kosher. ;)

Okay. Managed to somewhat organize my thoughts.

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject